The practice of ‘sin eating’ sits somewhere between religion and folkloric tradition and was once common in Wales, where a novel-in-waiting is set.

I’ve always been fascinated by the darker corners of history, particularly the traditions, superstitions and beliefs that sit somewhere between folklore and religion.
It’s often in these places, where fact and imagination become difficult to separate, that the most compelling stories can be found. The novel I’m currently working on, Consuming Shadows, grew out of one such fascination – the practice of sin eating.
Twenty-five years ago I visited Wales and found something deeply evocative about its countryside. Rolling green hills and ancient stone buildings seemed to hold their own histories. Mist settled across the hills and rain swept through the valleys, transforming the landscape from picturesque to brooding in a matter of moments. It was a place that seemed to invite stories.
A decade later, I came across an article about sin eating, a little-known practice in parts of Wales and the border counties I’d visited.
Sin eaters were believed to absorb the earthly transgressions of the recently deceased by consuming food and drink placed on or near the body, allowing the soul to pass into the afterlife unburdened. In return, they received a small payment for taking on another person’s sins.
It was an extraordinary transaction, equal parts religious ritual and unsettling folklore. I began to wonder what kind of story might emerge from the idea of one person carrying the moral burden of another.
There is something inherently gothic about the practice – the intimacy of sitting with the dead, the physical act of consuming another person’s sins, the idea that guilt can be transferred from one body to another.
I was drawn to what happens to the person who takes on that burden. Where does all that guilt go? What does it do to someone who spends their life absorbing the secrets, regrets and wrongdoing of others?
In Consuming Shadows, I’ve fictionalised that historical practice into something more personal and enduring. Rather than an occupation undertaken by an individual, sin eating becomes an ancient family responsibility, passed down through generations of women. It’s not a choice made freely. It’s an inheritance, with its own history, obligations and consequences.

The novel moves between 17th-century country Wales, a Welsh coastal village in 1969 and contemporary Brisbane.
At its heart are three generations of women – Arwen, Dilys and Anna, whose lives are shaped by the decisions of those who came before them.
In the modern storyline, Rickie discovers that the strange experiences she has always struggled to understand are connected to something her mother has spent a lifetime trying to conceal.
I wanted to explore the idea that family history is not always something we simply learn about; sometimes it’s something we carry. We inherit stories, expectations and, occasionally, the consequences of decisions made long before we were born. What if the guilt, grief and secrets of previous generations could be felt by their descendants?
This is where the fiction takes shape. The women in the family don’t just inherit the responsibility of sin eating; they inherit the memories and emotional residue of those who came before them. They experience the anguish of the dead, glimpse lives they have never lived and feel the weight of wrongdoing that’s not their own. The gift is also a curse, and each generation must find its own way of living with it.
The mother-daughter relationship is central. Dilys wants to protect Arwen from the truth of her past, just as Anna struggles to explain the family legacy to Rickie. Both mothers believe they are acting out of love, but their silence creates its own damage.
How much of our children’s lives do we have the right to shape in the name of keeping them safe? And when does withholding the truth become another form of inherited guilt?
One challenge has been balancing the historical and contemporary narratives. I wanted the 17th-century sections grounded in their landscape, with ritual and belief woven into everyday life, while the modern sections explore the same ideas without losing touch with the world we recognise.
Centuries apart, the emotional concerns remain strikingly similar: loyalty, betrayal, sacrifice, love and the difficulty of making choices whose consequences extend beyond ourselves.
I was curious about the physicality of sin eating. In the novel, the ritual involves salt, oatcakes and wine, and the sin eater experiences the memories and emotions of the deceased as she consumes the offering. The process is exhausting and sometimes physically violent. It’s not a gift that can be switched on and off at will. It has a cost.
There is a contradiction at the heart of the practice. The sin eater performs an act of compassion, but who takes care of her? And what of the inheritances that are never discussed, the secrets, compromises and shame that shape a family long after those responsible are gone?
After all, if we’re shaped by the lives of our ancestors, where does their story end and ours begin?
Helen Roche is an emerging writer of short stories, poetry and novels. She works at Queensland Writers Centre and has had articles published in WQ Magazine as well as self-publishing middle-grade novel, Amy and the Dreamtaker. She plans to complete Consuming Shadows in mid-2027.
This article was written as part of The Critical Writing Program, run in partnership with Queensland Writers Centre and InReview Queensland, supported by the Queensland Government through Arts Queensland, part of the Department of Education.
Want to see more stories from InDaily Qld in your Google search results?
This article may be shared online or in print under a Creative Commons licence