High notes and low deeds: It’s still elementary, my dear Watson

Sherlock Holmes is back at QPAC with uber thespian Eugene Gilfedder playing the famous sleuth.

Nov 16, 2026, updated Nov 16, 2026
Eugene Gilfedder, Ian Stenlake and Helen Howard star in Sherlock Holmes: The Mystery of the Valkyrie, now playing at QPAC.
Eugene Gilfedder, Ian Stenlake and Helen Howard star in Sherlock Holmes: The Mystery of the Valkyrie, now playing at QPAC.

A coded message. A dead body. A grand manor. A mysterious woman. Quick, search for clues. Leave no stone unturned, no alcove unchecked, no scratch unexamined. Nothing is as it seems. Everyone has something to hide. The game is certainly afoot.

Returning to Queensland after first premiering at QPAC in 2023, Sherlock Holmes: The Mystery of the Valkyrie tells an original story with Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s classic characters. Holmes and Watson investigate a grisly murder at Birlstone Manor, only for their routine case to evolve into a full-blown criminal conspiracy helmed by Holmes’ greatest and most-feared rival, Professor Moriarty.

These characters are embodied by an all-star cast who truly capture the Holmesian experience. Eugene Gilfedder and Bryan Probets reprise their roles as Holmes and Moriarty from the 2023 production, and are joined by Ian Stenlake as Dr John Watson and Helen Howard as Irene Adler.

Eugene Gilfedder reprises his role as Sherlock Holmes in an original story with Sir Arthur Conan Doyle’s classic characters.

Gilfedder and Stenlake’s chemistry as Holmes and Watson is exceptional, playing off one another effortlessly in scenes that depict Watson’s kind and supportive nature rubbing against Holmes’ calculating and often cold demeanour.

Alongside this, Probets’ Moriarty is charmingly ruthless, stealing the spotlight every time he is on stage. Finally, Howard plays Adler superbly, constantly making the audience question how much her character actually knows.

Assisting this stellar cast in bringing Victorian London to life is the equally impressive set design, courtesy of Isabel Hudson and Craig Wilkinson. Alcoves and staircases are wheeled across the stage to build the halls of Birlstone Manor, the grand opera house, and the legendary cramped home of Holmes – 221B Baker Street.

The set pieces are moved mid-scene during action-heavy moments to create the sense of characters traversing much larger spaces, giving these scenes an enhanced sense of scale.

 Clever use of physical and digital set dressing comes together marvellously in Sherlock Holmes: The Mystery of the Valkyrie, now at QPAC.

Subscribe for updates

Paired with this are video projections cast upon the props, adding further detail. In the background, landscape vistas are shown to give scenes greater depth, replaced with close-ups of characters, props and events when Holmes makes a breakthrough on the case.

This clever use of physical and digital set dressing comes together marvellously, making the sets and locations as real and tangible as the characters themselves.

But, unfortunately, not everything about this production reaches these great heights. The central mystery at the heart of the show feels less like a grand, overarching secret with clues scattered throughout the performance, and more like a series of questions and answers.

Often, characters will present vital information needed for the solving of the mystery right at the moment when they reveal the solution, not leaving enough time or clues for the audience to mentally assemble the pieces for themselves. This may feel unsatisfying to lovers of mystery novels, because it makes the solutions seem as though they are a surprise, rather than a puzzle that could actually be solved.

This should not detract from the value of this production. The Mystery of the Valkyrie is worthwhile viewing for the performances alone, and despite the mystery being somewhat elementary in execution, the play is tense and engaging, with great character moments that feel as though Holmes and Watson walked right off the page and into the theatre.

This, alongside the magnificent set design, leave no mystery as to why this production is back at QPAC.

Sherlock Holmes: The Mystery of the Valkyrie continues at the Playhouse, QPAC, until November 29.

qpac.com.au/whats-on/2026/sherlock-holmes-the-mystery-of-the-valkyrie

This article was written as part of  The Critical Writing Program, run in partnership with Queensland Writers Centre and InReview Queensland, supported by the Queensland Government through Arts Queensland, part of the Department of Education. 

Want to see more stories from InDaily Qld in your Google search results?

  1. Click here to set InDaily Qld as a preferred source.
  2. Tick the box next to "InDaily Qld". That's it.

Free to share

This article may be shared online or in print under a Creative Commons licence